• ES
  • EN
Fundeps
  • About Fundeps
  • Team
  • Working areas
    • Environment
    • Democracy
    • Gender
    • Global Gorvernance
    • Health
  • News
  • Publications
  • DONATE
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu
Environment, News

Revocation of the order to carry out studies on environmental contamination in Porta Hnos.’s case

On February 22, the Federal Court of Appeals of Córdoba, by majority vote, decided to revoke the resolution issued by the Federal Court No. 3 of Córdoba in the context of the Porta Hermanos case. In that resolution, studies were ordered on environmental contamination and possible pathologies present in the vicinity of the plant of Porta Hermanos S.A.

“Below, we offer a google translate version of the original article in Spanish. This translation may not be accurate but serves as a general presentation of the article. For more accurate information, please switch to the Spanish version of the website. In addition, feel free to directly contact in English the person mentioned at the bottom of this article with regards to this topic”.

The Federal Court of Appeals made the appeal filed by the company Porta Hermanos SA, revoking the ruling by the Federal Court No. 3 in which the case is processed “CRUZ, SILVIA MARCELA AND OTHERS v MINISTERIO DE ENERGÍA Y MINERÍA DE THE NATION s / AMPARO ENVIRONMENTAL “. In this resolution Judge Vaca Narvaja ordered, on the one hand, the Environmental Research Center – Department of Chemistry of the Faculty of Exact Sciences of the National University of La Plata to inform the court the feasibility of carrying out a study on the possible environmental contamination at the Porta plant, and on the other hand, to the Dean of the Faculty of Medical Sciences of the same University in order to evaluate the possibility of carrying out an inspection on 100 people living in the vicinity of the plant to detect possible pathologies .

The majority vote, maintains that the aforementioned resolution violates the principle of procedural consistency since the measures ordered by the judge of first instance, do not correlate with the object of the amparo filed by those affected. Recall that the principle of procedural consistency implies that the court can not go beyond what was requested by the parties or base its decision on facts different from those that have been alleged by the parties. In this case, the Chamber also maintains that, even though the intervening judge is assisted by the powers provided for in Article 32 of Law 25,675 – which refer to a judge with an active role, concerned about the protection of a collective good such as is the environment-, they must be applied with restrictions. According to the court, these powers are limited only to knowledge of the positions of the parties, thus giving primacy to the principle of congruence over such powers.

Given this panorama, it is necessary to make certain precisions:

The vote analyzed, maintains that the purpose of the amparo revolves around elucidating whether the bioethanol plant of the company Porta Hermanos required:

  • Authorization to operate by the Ex Secretariat of Energy of the Nation
  • Conducting the Environmental Impact Assessment procedure before putting it into operation

The principle of congruence, the precautionary principle and the environmental perspective.

First, from the reading of the same resolution, it is clear that the “environmental protection” presented by the neighbors, has as its main object the “cessation of atmospheric environmental pollution” by the bioethanol plant of the company Porta Hermanos SA In this line, it is requested the closure and final closure of the plant attentive to not having complied with the procedure of Environmental Impact Assessment – “lack of legal authorization”. Well, if the claim focuses on the cessation of environmental pollution, it is fully consistent to determine the existence of such a phenomenon. Indeed, it would be impossible to stop a contamination, which in the facts has not been fully proven.

Without prejudice to this, the precautionary principle comes into play since, even in the face of uncertainty, the judge could not postpone effective measures for the protection of the environment. In the resolution analyzed here, the majority vote ignores the claim of the amparistas, which is closely linked to the measures ordered by the Federal Judge, not violating the principle of congruence.

The administrative authorizations can not be permits to pollute.

Second, even when the object of environmental protection is that identified by the Chamber, that is, the need for a legal authorization, it is necessary to consider that what underlies the formal administrative procedures for authorization is the protection of the environment. Thus, the formal permits constitute a presumption of safety of the activity enabled but do not imply a permission to pollute and damage the environment, so that, upon verification of a polluting activity, such presumption must yield.

In other words, the debate on the need for an authorization or not, basically, involves discussing whether such activity harms the environment in a way that would have required the prevention and / or management of damage through the impact assessment procedures environmental (in accordance with the provisions of Art. 11 of Law 25,675). Therefore, even in such an object, the measures ordered by the federal judge of the 1st Instance, are fully congruent.

The preventive role of the courts in environmental processes.

In the third place, the assertion made by the Chamber that the principle of procedural consistency prevails over the powers granted by Art. 32 of Law 25,675 (L.G.A), is questionable, if not erroneous.

In the processes where the environmental issue is debated, because of the well protected, the rights at stake and the particularity of the damage, it is necessary that the traditional procedural rules (read principle of congruence) are redefined from the environmental and human rights perspective. The judge acquires a preventive role and an active role in pursuit of the effective protection of the general interest, being able to adopt the necessary measures and measures (Art. 32 L.G.A). In such a role, the judge must act in favor of the protection of the general environmental interest, which acquires a preeminent value, modifying the traditional rules of the civil process, in order to prevent environmental damage, without falling into the stillness of allowing the pollution and thereby consolidate irreparable environmental damage. Under this pre-eminence, the principle of congruence is subverted, or cedes in favor of environmental protection.

It should be noted that the resolution adopted by the Federal Court of Appeals of Córdoba, is questionable as it erroneously defines the object of environmental protection as merely formal (determine the need for legal authorization), and ignores principles and fundamental rules of Argentine environmental public order. In addition, in this case the resolution revoked simply ordered measures to have more information of the current situation, something that has been the cause of successive public complaints by neighbors in the neighborhoods San Antonio and Inaudi.

It is unfortunate that a formalistic look away from reality prevents having more information, in order to better investigate and evaluate a situation of socio-environmental conflict that has been in our city for years.

More information

  • See complete failure

Author

Juan Bautista Lopez

  • Contact

María Pérez Alsina, mariaperezalsina@fundeps.org

13 de March de 2019
Tags: Access to Justice, Environment, Human Rights and Companies, Urban Development
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail
https://fundeps.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/Porta-web.jpg 600 900 Comunicaciones Fundeps https://fundeps.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/logo-2026-300x120.png Comunicaciones Fundeps2019-03-13 14:09:012024-06-30 16:03:06Revocation of the order to carry out studies on environmental contamination in Porta Hnos.’s case
You might also like
The province of Córdoba adhered to the Yolanda Law
We participate in the First Latin American Workshop on Litigation Strategies on Climate Change and Human Rights
One of lime and one of sand in the case against Porta Hnos.
We want San Roque Lake clean now!
Climate Change and Open Government at the Global TAI Meeting
We participated in the 13th United Nations Forum on Business and Human Rights
From Córdoba to Brazil: Environmental defenders in the Inter-American Court of Human Rights
The exploitation of lithium in the high Andean salt flats: a socio-environmental analysis based on the Argentine case

Tags

Access to Information Access to Justice BID Chinese Investments Citizen Participation Democracy ENTs Environment Environmental Democracy Gender Global Governance Health Healthy nutrition IFIs Infrastructure Financing Legal Interruption of Pregnancy Sexual and Reproductive Rights Social and Environmental Standards Tobacco Control Transparency
See all tags

Acuerdo de Escazú

Emergencia Agroquímica

MOCI - monitoreo ciudadano en proyectos de infraestructura

{el entramado} Contamos historias. Acercamos Realidades.

Instagram

fundepsargentina

Trabajamos para que se garanticen los derechos humanos 🌱⚖️🗣️🌈💜🚭🍎
Promovemos la equidad de #genero, el derecho a la #salud y un #ambiente sano.

Así vivimos la Primera Jornada de Salud y Derechos Así vivimos la Primera Jornada de Salud y Derechos con Perspectiva de Diversidad en el Valle de Calamuchita 🏳️‍🌈

Desde Fundeps y Orgullo Calamuchita realizamos este primer encuentro regional en Santa Rosa de Calamuchita, más de 80 personas involucradas en total, entre expositoras, invitadas y equipo organizador, provenientes de distintas localidades del Valle.

✏️Durante la jornada compartimos experiencias y herramientas para reconocer barreras en el acceso a la salud, abordar las experiencias trans, travestis y no binarias en las distintas etapas de la vida, y transformar prácticas atravesadas por prejuicios y violencias.

También construimos colectivamente un Mapa de Compromisos, identificando acciones posibles desde nuestros distintos espacios de trabajo.

Porque garantizar el acceso a la salud sexual integral con perspectiva de diversidad es un derecho y una responsabilidad de todo el sistema sanitario. Necesitamos equipos que se formen, instituciones comprometidas y redes de trabajo que construyan respuestas en cada territorio.

Celebramos el aval y acompañamiento de la Secretaría de Derechos Humanos y Diversidad de la provincia, y de la Municipalidad de Santa Rosa de Calamuchita, así como la presencia del Programa Provincial de Acceso a la Salud Integral LGTTBIQ+ perteneciente a la DAJA del Ministerio de Salud de Córdoba. Agradecemos también a la Comisión del Centro de Fomento Villa Río Santa Rosa y al Estudio BLÁ por su apoyo incondicional y el registro audiovisual.

Y a todas las personas, organizaciones e instituciones que hicieron posible este encuentro y que se sumaron a construir colectivamente una salud más inclusiva, respetuosa y libre de discriminación. GRACIAS!

📸 @bla.comunicacion
¡Cumplimos 17 años! Nos llena de orgullo mirar to ¡Cumplimos 17 años!

Nos llena de orgullo mirar todo lo que fuimos construyendo y el impacto que logramos impulsar a lo largo de estos años.

Detrás de cada logro  hay años de trabajo, compromiso y muchas personas que hicieron posible que Fundeps siga creciendo: quienes forman y formaron parte del equipo, las organizaciones con las que articulamos, las comunidades que nos abrieron sus puertas y quienes nos acompañan y apoyan.

17 años defendiendo derechos y construyendo colectivamente.

Gracias por ser parte de esta historia. Vamos por mucho más!
¡Es broma, pero no es mentira! La industria tabac ¡Es broma, pero no es mentira!

La industria tabacalera usa las redes sociales para captar a una nueva generación de consumidores, principalmente adolescentes y jóvenes.

Su principal estrategia es la promoción de bolsas de nicotina y vapers. 

🚫 Aunque hoy se permite vender estos productos, publicitarlos sigue siendo ilegal. Sin embargo, las propias marcas lo hacen de forma sistemática y a la vista de todo el mundo, porque nadie las controla ni las sanciona.

🕵🏻‍♀️Lo comprobamos en nuestra última investigación, en la que monitoreamos publicaciones de Instagram durante 2 meses. 

Exijamos que el Estado haga cumplir la ley para proteger la salud de adolescentes y jóvenes. ✊

📲 Compartí este posteo y leé el informe completo en el link de nuestra bio.

#ControlDeTabaco #BolsasDeNicotina #Vapers #Salud
¡Las Pérez Correa + conversatorio femi = planazo! ¡Las Pérez Correa + conversatorio femi = planazo!

¡TENEMOS NUEVA FECHA! El jueves 19 de noviembre nos encontramos para hablar de aborto, derechos y autonomías feministas, con una intervención artística de Las Pérez Correa para arrancar la tarde.

Después, panel con referentes para conversar sobre el acceso al aborto y los desafíos que tenemos por delante en Córdoba.

19/11 · 18 h · Auditorio del CePIA, Facultad de Artes UNC

Actividad libre y gratuita.

¡Ahora sí, agendalo! Nos vemos ahí.
Follow on Instagram

Twitter

Tweets por @fundeps

Newsletter Subscription

    Fundeps. Córdoba (CP X5000JZH), Argentina. info@fundeps.org
    • Link to X
    • Link to Facebook
    • Link to Instagram
    • Link to Mail
    • Link to Youtube
    • Link to LinkedIn
    • Link to TikTok
    Link to: More than 100 organizations are calling on EITI to publish environmental information Link to: More than 100 organizations are calling on EITI to publish environmental information More than 100 organizations are calling on EITI to publish environmental in... Link to: Climate change and human rights: request for a thematic hearing before the IACHR Link to: Climate change and human rights: request for a thematic hearing before the IACHR Climate change and human rights: request for a thematic hearing before the ...
    Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top