• ES
  • EN
Fundeps
  • About Fundeps
  • Team
  • Working areas
    • Environment
    • Democracy
    • Gender
    • Global Gorvernance
    • Health
  • News
  • Publications
  • DONATE
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu
News

Civil Society Organizations’ critics to bank interpretations on human rights responsibilities

The Bank Group of Thun published a document about the implications of the UN Guiding Principles for corporate and investment banking. A group of civil society organizations publicly criticise these statements.

“Below, we offer a google translate version of the original article in Spanish. This translation may not be accurate but serves as a general presentation of the article. For more accurate information, please switch to the Spanish version of the website. In addition, feel free to directly contact in English the person mentioned at the bottom of this article with regards to this topic.”

 

Faced with the risks involved in the Thun Group document, a group of civil society organizations issued an open letter criticizing many of the issues raised in that document. We signed the letter 34 academic and civil society organizations from 17 countries, including BankTrack, SOMO, Oxfam, Greenpeace, Global Witness and OECD Watch.

The Thun Group document develops a conceptual framework for the implementation of the Guiding Principles on Transnational Corporations and Human Rights for banks in a context of corporate and investment banking. This document misrepresents principle 13.

The letter requests that the Thun Group demonstrate that it is prepared to participate in the OECD Proactive Agenda Project in good faith by amending the document they have issued and making it clear that it recognizes and respects the advice of the Office of the High Commissioner for United Nations for Human Rights.

The guiding principles are a set of guidelines agreed upon by the international community as a guideline that guides both States in their work to protect human rights and companies in their duty to respect them. This work was led by Professor Ruggie. These principles were adopted unanimously in 2011 by the United Nations Human Rights Council.

In this context, on 21 February, Professor Ruggie of Harvard responded strongly to the Thun Group document. He is “deeply concerned” by the document and raises similar points to those of the open letter. “They can undermine attempts by banks and others to fulfill their responsibility to respect human rights.” In addition, he adds that:

“It is a good example that a group of large banks are doing important work on the application of UNGPs to their sector. But I am afraid that misinterpretation of the basic elements of UNGPs and their implications in this document can seriously damage I would urge the Group to reflect on these issues and consider the possibility of issuing a future document more in line with the basic elements of the UNGPs.”

On 23 February, the coordinator of the United Nations Working Group promoting the implementation of the Guiding Principles for Business and Human Rights also responded by inviting Thun Group banks to review the document “to align it with UNGPs” The Working Group considers that the discussion paper offers some useful practical considerations for banks in certain situations where they may be directly linked to the effects of human rights through the financial products or services they provide to third parties , Which may contribute or cause a human rights conflict abuse.

“The efforts of the Thun Group to explore the practical implications of the UNGPs are welcome … However, these instruments of practice that seek to interpret the meaning of UNGPs in a sector-specific context should be subject to a consultation process And review by other stakeholders in order to ensure accuracy, soundness and legitimacy. “

The Working Group believes that if not addressed, this can cause unnecessary confusion on UNGPs, which may undermine attempts by banks and others to fulfill their responsibility to respect human rights. It should be noted that the discussion paper of the Thun Group was approved by Barclays, BBVA, BNP Paribas, Credit Suisse AG, Deutsche Bank, ING, JPMorgan, RBS, Standard Chartered, UBS Group AG and UniCredit.

On 28 February Christian Leitz on behalf of the Thun Group responded to the CSO group, Professor John Ruggie and the UN Working Group. He claims to be trying to generate a constructive discussion between banks and other interested parties but has not indicated any willingness to revise the document. And it hopes to continue with stakeholders in upcoming multi-stakeholder forums by discussing the document.

A meeting open to all signatories of the letter is scheduled for 19 June where a broader dialogue with the Thun Group will take place. Professor Ruggie has said he will consider participating in this meeting if they retracted the premise that banks can not contribute to damage through their relationships with customers.

In the counter response, civil society organizations express two concerns about the June meeting. On the one hand, define a stakeholder engagement strategy as promised by the Thun Group at its last public meeting. And secondly, that you withdraw and reconsider your recent document.

From FUNDEPS we follow this process and we expect a change in the response that has given the Thun Group. The Guiding Principles on Transnational Corporations and Human Rights were created to “protect, respect and remedy” human rights, and we expect cooperation from states, private sectors and civil society to fulfill their commitments.

More information

Thun Group of Banks releases new Discussion Paper on implications of UN Guiding Principles for corporate & investment banking; commentaries provided

Leading banks under fire for misrepresenting human rights responsibilities

Contact

Victoria Gerbaldo / Encargada de Proyectos del Área de Gobernabilidad Global

victoriagerbaldo@fundeps.org

16 de March de 2017
Tags: Global Governance, Human Rights and Companies
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail
https://fundeps.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/trasnacionales-700x350-2.jpg 330 750 Fundeps.org https://fundeps.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/logo-2026-300x120.png Fundeps.org2017-03-16 22:26:292024-06-30 16:04:11Civil Society Organizations’ critics to bank interpretations on human rights responsibilities
You might also like
We invite you to the National Forum of Gender Policies in Journalism and Advertising
Actions that transform: see our Annuary 2023
Trunk gas pipelines: What will happen to the most vulnerable population?
Why does Argentina still not have a National Action Plan on Business and Human Rights?
Trunk Gas Pipelines and the difficulty of accessing public information in the province
Civil Society Organizations and Communities Call for Respect for Rights at the IDB Annual Meeting in Asunción
We demand participation and transparency in the change of direction of the MICI
China’s growing role in funding the development of Latin America

Tags

Access to Information Access to Justice BID Chinese Investments Citizen Participation Democracy ENTs Environment Environmental Democracy Gender Global Governance Health Healthy nutrition IFIs Infrastructure Financing Legal Interruption of Pregnancy Sexual and Reproductive Rights Social and Environmental Standards Tobacco Control Transparency
See all tags

Acuerdo de Escazú

Emergencia Agroquímica

MOCI - monitoreo ciudadano en proyectos de infraestructura

{el entramado} Contamos historias. Acercamos Realidades.

Instagram

fundepsargentina

Trabajamos para que se garanticen los derechos humanos 🌱⚖️🗣️🌈💜🚭🍎
Promovemos la equidad de #genero, el derecho a la #salud y un #ambiente sano.

Así vivimos la Primera Jornada de Salud y Derechos Así vivimos la Primera Jornada de Salud y Derechos con Perspectiva de Diversidad en el Valle de Calamuchita 🏳️‍🌈

Desde Fundeps y Orgullo Calamuchita realizamos este primer encuentro regional en Santa Rosa de Calamuchita, más de 80 personas involucradas en total, entre expositoras, invitadas y equipo organizador, provenientes de distintas localidades del Valle.

✏️Durante la jornada compartimos experiencias y herramientas para reconocer barreras en el acceso a la salud, abordar las experiencias trans, travestis y no binarias en las distintas etapas de la vida, y transformar prácticas atravesadas por prejuicios y violencias.

También construimos colectivamente un Mapa de Compromisos, identificando acciones posibles desde nuestros distintos espacios de trabajo.

Porque garantizar el acceso a la salud sexual integral con perspectiva de diversidad es un derecho y una responsabilidad de todo el sistema sanitario. Necesitamos equipos que se formen, instituciones comprometidas y redes de trabajo que construyan respuestas en cada territorio.

Celebramos el aval y acompañamiento de la Secretaría de Derechos Humanos y Diversidad de la provincia, y de la Municipalidad de Santa Rosa de Calamuchita, así como la presencia del Programa Provincial de Acceso a la Salud Integral LGTTBIQ+ perteneciente a la DAJA del Ministerio de Salud de Córdoba. Agradecemos también a la Comisión del Centro de Fomento Villa Río Santa Rosa y al Estudio BLÁ por su apoyo incondicional y el registro audiovisual.

Y a todas las personas, organizaciones e instituciones que hicieron posible este encuentro y que se sumaron a construir colectivamente una salud más inclusiva, respetuosa y libre de discriminación. GRACIAS!

📸 @bla.comunicacion
¡Cumplimos 17 años! Nos llena de orgullo mirar to ¡Cumplimos 17 años!

Nos llena de orgullo mirar todo lo que fuimos construyendo y el impacto que logramos impulsar a lo largo de estos años.

Detrás de cada logro  hay años de trabajo, compromiso y muchas personas que hicieron posible que Fundeps siga creciendo: quienes forman y formaron parte del equipo, las organizaciones con las que articulamos, las comunidades que nos abrieron sus puertas y quienes nos acompañan y apoyan.

17 años defendiendo derechos y construyendo colectivamente.

Gracias por ser parte de esta historia. Vamos por mucho más!
¡Es broma, pero no es mentira! La industria tabac ¡Es broma, pero no es mentira!

La industria tabacalera usa las redes sociales para captar a una nueva generación de consumidores, principalmente adolescentes y jóvenes.

Su principal estrategia es la promoción de bolsas de nicotina y vapers. 

🚫 Aunque hoy se permite vender estos productos, publicitarlos sigue siendo ilegal. Sin embargo, las propias marcas lo hacen de forma sistemática y a la vista de todo el mundo, porque nadie las controla ni las sanciona.

🕵🏻‍♀️Lo comprobamos en nuestra última investigación, en la que monitoreamos publicaciones de Instagram durante 2 meses. 

Exijamos que el Estado haga cumplir la ley para proteger la salud de adolescentes y jóvenes. ✊

📲 Compartí este posteo y leé el informe completo en el link de nuestra bio.

#ControlDeTabaco #BolsasDeNicotina #Vapers #Salud
¡Las Pérez Correa + conversatorio femi = planazo! ¡Las Pérez Correa + conversatorio femi = planazo!

¡TENEMOS NUEVA FECHA! El jueves 19 de noviembre nos encontramos para hablar de aborto, derechos y autonomías feministas, con una intervención artística de Las Pérez Correa para arrancar la tarde.

Después, panel con referentes para conversar sobre el acceso al aborto y los desafíos que tenemos por delante en Córdoba.

19/11 · 18 h · Auditorio del CePIA, Facultad de Artes UNC

Actividad libre y gratuita.

¡Ahora sí, agendalo! Nos vemos ahí.
Follow on Instagram

Twitter

Tweets por @fundeps

Newsletter Subscription

    Fundeps. Córdoba (CP X5000JZH), Argentina. info@fundeps.org
    • Link to X
    • Link to Facebook
    • Link to Instagram
    • Link to Mail
    • Link to Youtube
    • Link to LinkedIn
    • Link to TikTok
    Link to: The ICIM External Consultative Group was formed Link to: The ICIM External Consultative Group was formed The ICIM External Consultative Group was formed Link to: We participated in the regional hearing of the IACHR in pursuit of compliance with the DESCA Link to: We participated in the regional hearing of the IACHR in pursuit of compliance with the DESCA We participated in the regional hearing of the IACHR in pursuit of compliance...
    Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top