• ES
  • EN
Fundeps
  • About Fundeps
  • Team
  • Working areas
    • Environment
    • Democracy
    • Gender
    • Global Gorvernance
    • Health
  • News
  • Publications
  • DONATE
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu
Environment, News

Irresponsible Mining: One Month After the Glacier Law Reform

The reform to the Glacier Law approved on April 7 did more than weaken a law. It set a troubling precedent: environmental protection standards can be rolled back when they come into conflict with large-scale economic interests. This not only compromises the present, but also undermines the State’s ability to guarantee rights in the future, putting new generations at risk.

From a regulatory perspective, mining activities operate within a framework that combines outdated historical legislation —such as the Mining Code of 1885— with investment promotion regimes —such as Law 24,196— and new economic incentive mechanisms like the Large Investment Incentive Regime (RIGI).

Combined with the weakening of political, regulatory, and institutional environmental protection tools, this creates a scenario that prioritizes attracting investment over protecting common goods and fundamental rights.

The Last Straw

This reform represents a substantial alteration to Argentina’s current environmental protection system, particularly regarding the protection of water as a strategic legal asset.

The existing framework, based on scientific and technical standards and the precautionary principle, had made it possible to establish reasonable common limits on extractive activities in highly fragile ecosystems.

To better understand what is at stake, it is important to recognize that large-scale metal mining, as it currently operates in the country, has a structural dependence on water resources. Large-scale mining depends on water in order to exist and expand. The communities living in these areas do as well. And water is far from an infinite resource.

According to information disclosed in environmental assessment instruments, projects such as Alumbrera in the province of Catamarca —now entering a new reopening phase with estimated extraction levels lower than during its peak years— project water consumption between 3 and 5 million liters per day in their upcoming stages.

If we calculate an —already excessive— consumption of 150 liters of drinking water per person per day, then even in the best-case scenario this project would consume, every single day, the amount of water needed by the entire population of towns such as Agua de Oro in Córdoba, Lago Puelo in Chubut, or Tafí Viejo in Tucumán.

Meanwhile, ongoing operations such as Veladero report water consumption levels close to 9 million liters per day — three times that amount.

Moreover, these levels of use must be analyzed in light of their location: arid or semi-arid regions where water is scarce and strategically critical.

This, and nothing else, explains why disputes over water have existed for decades. Examples include Famatina, Esquel, Andalgalá, Chubut, and Mendoza. Local communities, aware of the importance of this resource for both present survival and future development, organize, educate themselves, and sustain resistance strategies over many years. Because water is essential not only for the survival of communities, but also for sustaining regional microeconomies.

These environmental defenders protect not only water, but also a way of life and a development model that successive governments continue to ignore. Anyone reading this would do the same in their place, because this is about defending their own survival and that of the place where they live.

As resistance grows stronger, the social license required for mining development becomes an increasingly difficult aspiration for companies to achieve.

Irresponsible Mining

Water, essential for the lives of communities, is being made available to the mining agenda promoted by the national government and several provincial governments, which present it as the only development alternative for especially arid regions of the country.

Those defending the reform promise responsible mining and legal certainty for corporations. But what kind of “responsible mining” are we talking about? Which companies are behind this reform?

As is already well known, this reform is the result of mining lobbying by multinational corporations that dominate the sector, including Glencore, Barrick, BHP, and First Quantum Minerals.

Glencore, linked to projects such as MARA in Catamarca and El Pachón in the province of San Juan —and backed by the hedge fund BlackRock— has been criminally convicted for corruption in jurisdictions such as the United States and the United Kingdom. The company also faces multiple proceedings over socio-environmental impacts not only in Argentina but in different parts of the world, including the Democratic Republic of the Congo, the Philippines, and Peru. These allegations range from water contamination to the killing of environmental defenders.

Barrick Gold, for its part, has faced allegations related to human rights and environmental violations, including reports of sexual violence in Papua New Guinea and deaths and violent repression in Tanzania. In 2018, the company received a ruling that included the permanent closure of the Pascua Lama project in Chile after serious breaches involving water resource protection and glacier environments were confirmed.

Likewise, BHP, involved in the development of the Vicuña project, has faced allegations of violations of Indigenous rights and labor rights abuses. The company was responsible for the collapse of the Samarco tailings dam in Brazil in 2015, considered one of the most significant environmental disasters in the region and currently the subject of major international litigation.

Similarly, First Quantum Minerals, promoter of the Taca Taca project in Salta, was involved in a judicial process in Panama that culminated in 2023 when that country’s Supreme Court declared the mining contract unconstitutional for violating multiple constitutional provisions, including environmental protection principles and fundamental rights.

These records cannot be treated as isolated incidents. They are part of a global pattern in which extractive expansion often occurs at the expense of fragile ecosystems, strategic water sources, and community rights.

Faced with companies that dominate the global industry, exert enormous pressure, and relentlessly pursue natural resources, it is impossible to believe that provinces already overwhelmed by economic crisis can effectively protect glaciers, water resources, or build truly sustainable development.

Legal Uncertainty

For these reasons, the debate surrounding the Glacier Law reform was never merely a technical or sector-specific discussion.

This became evident in the massive social mobilization preceding the legislative debate and in the more than 100,000 people registered for the Public Hearing — a hearing that failed to comply with existing regulations and minimum democratic standards.

Furthermore, the reform violated both the principle of progressivity and the precautionary principle, constituting a clearly unconstitutional regression that is likely to trigger dozens of legal actions, ultimately undermining the promised “legal certainty.”

In light of these precedents, claiming that weakening the Glacier Law will pave the way for “responsible” mining is highly questionable. Without strict environmental standards, effective oversight, and genuine community participation, risks do not decrease — they increase.

Continuing to defend the Glacier Law is not opposing development. It is affirming that development cannot be built at the expense of water, territories, and communities.

Author: María Laura Carrizo, Fundeps
Contact: lauracarrizo@fundeps.org

7 de May de 2026
Tags: Energy transition, Environmental Democracy, Mining
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail
https://fundeps.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/Defender-la-Ley-de-Glaciares-es-defender-el-agua-la-vida-y-el-futuro.-710-x-375-px-710-x-321-px_11zon.webp 321 710 Paula Hernández https://fundeps.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/logo-2026-300x120.png Paula Hernández2026-05-07 12:00:372026-05-18 13:16:50Irresponsible Mining: One Month After the Glacier Law Reform
You might also like
Report: Demands and Challenges in Access to Public Environmental Information
We adhere to the statement against the aggression against environmental defenders at the UNC
Argentina ratified the Escazú Agreement
FUNDEPS participates in the Annual Meeting of the World Bank and the IMF, dominated by the review of the World Bank’s environmental and social safeguards
From Córdoba to Brazil: Environmental defenders in the Inter-American Court of Human Rights
We reject the modification of the mining law in Mendoza
We repudiate the criminalization of Environmental and Territorial Defenders of Punilla
We participate in the Environment and Education Commission of the Provincial Legislature

Tags

Access to Information Access to Justice BID Chinese Investments Citizen Participation Democracy ENTs Environment Environmental Democracy Gender Global Governance Health Healthy nutrition IFIs Infrastructure Financing Legal Interruption of Pregnancy Sexual and Reproductive Rights Social and Environmental Standards Tobacco Control Transparency
See all tags

Acuerdo de Escazú

Emergencia Agroquímica

MOCI - monitoreo ciudadano en proyectos de infraestructura

{el entramado} Contamos historias. Acercamos Realidades.

Instagram

fundepsargentina

Trabajamos para que se garanticen los derechos humanos 🌱⚖️🗣️🌈💜🚭🍎
Promovemos la equidad de #genero, el derecho a la #salud y un #ambiente sano.

Así vivimos la Primera Jornada de Salud y Derechos Así vivimos la Primera Jornada de Salud y Derechos con Perspectiva de Diversidad en el Valle de Calamuchita 🏳️‍🌈

Desde Fundeps y Orgullo Calamuchita realizamos este primer encuentro regional en Santa Rosa de Calamuchita, más de 80 personas involucradas en total, entre expositoras, invitadas y equipo organizador, provenientes de distintas localidades del Valle.

✏️Durante la jornada compartimos experiencias y herramientas para reconocer barreras en el acceso a la salud, abordar las experiencias trans, travestis y no binarias en las distintas etapas de la vida, y transformar prácticas atravesadas por prejuicios y violencias.

También construimos colectivamente un Mapa de Compromisos, identificando acciones posibles desde nuestros distintos espacios de trabajo.

Porque garantizar el acceso a la salud sexual integral con perspectiva de diversidad es un derecho y una responsabilidad de todo el sistema sanitario. Necesitamos equipos que se formen, instituciones comprometidas y redes de trabajo que construyan respuestas en cada territorio.

Celebramos el aval y acompañamiento de la Secretaría de Derechos Humanos y Diversidad de la provincia, y de la Municipalidad de Santa Rosa de Calamuchita, así como la presencia del Programa Provincial de Acceso a la Salud Integral LGTTBIQ+ perteneciente a la DAJA del Ministerio de Salud de Córdoba. Agradecemos también a la Comisión del Centro de Fomento Villa Río Santa Rosa y al Estudio BLÁ por su apoyo incondicional y el registro audiovisual.

Y a todas las personas, organizaciones e instituciones que hicieron posible este encuentro y que se sumaron a construir colectivamente una salud más inclusiva, respetuosa y libre de discriminación. GRACIAS!

📸 @bla.comunicacion
¡Cumplimos 17 años! Nos llena de orgullo mirar to ¡Cumplimos 17 años!

Nos llena de orgullo mirar todo lo que fuimos construyendo y el impacto que logramos impulsar a lo largo de estos años.

Detrás de cada logro  hay años de trabajo, compromiso y muchas personas que hicieron posible que Fundeps siga creciendo: quienes forman y formaron parte del equipo, las organizaciones con las que articulamos, las comunidades que nos abrieron sus puertas y quienes nos acompañan y apoyan.

17 años defendiendo derechos y construyendo colectivamente.

Gracias por ser parte de esta historia. Vamos por mucho más!
¡Es broma, pero no es mentira! La industria tabac ¡Es broma, pero no es mentira!

La industria tabacalera usa las redes sociales para captar a una nueva generación de consumidores, principalmente adolescentes y jóvenes.

Su principal estrategia es la promoción de bolsas de nicotina y vapers. 

🚫 Aunque hoy se permite vender estos productos, publicitarlos sigue siendo ilegal. Sin embargo, las propias marcas lo hacen de forma sistemática y a la vista de todo el mundo, porque nadie las controla ni las sanciona.

🕵🏻‍♀️Lo comprobamos en nuestra última investigación, en la que monitoreamos publicaciones de Instagram durante 2 meses. 

Exijamos que el Estado haga cumplir la ley para proteger la salud de adolescentes y jóvenes. ✊

📲 Compartí este posteo y leé el informe completo en el link de nuestra bio.

#ControlDeTabaco #BolsasDeNicotina #Vapers #Salud
¡Las Pérez Correa + conversatorio femi = planazo! ¡Las Pérez Correa + conversatorio femi = planazo!

¡TENEMOS NUEVA FECHA! El jueves 19 de noviembre nos encontramos para hablar de aborto, derechos y autonomías feministas, con una intervención artística de Las Pérez Correa para arrancar la tarde.

Después, panel con referentes para conversar sobre el acceso al aborto y los desafíos que tenemos por delante en Córdoba.

19/11 · 18 h · Auditorio del CePIA, Facultad de Artes UNC

Actividad libre y gratuita.

¡Ahora sí, agendalo! Nos vemos ahí.
Follow on Instagram

Twitter

Tweets por @fundeps

Newsletter Subscription

    Fundeps. Córdoba (CP X5000JZH), Argentina. info@fundeps.org
    • Link to X
    • Link to Facebook
    • Link to Instagram
    • Link to Mail
    • Link to Youtube
    • Link to LinkedIn
    • Link to TikTok
    Link to: Setback for Public Health: Argentina Authorizes the Commercialization of Electronic Cigarettes and Heated Tobacco Products Link to: Setback for Public Health: Argentina Authorizes the Commercialization of Electronic Cigarettes and Heated Tobacco Products Setback for Public Health: Argentina Authorizes the Commercialization of Electronic... Link to: The Right to Food in Argentina: Implications and Challenges of the Healthy Eating Promotion Law in the Context of Emergency Food Policies Link to: The Right to Food in Argentina: Implications and Challenges of the Healthy Eating Promotion Law in the Context of Emergency Food Policies The Right to Food in Argentina: Implications and Challenges of the Healthy Eating...
    Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top